• Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Vimeo
  • FCUS Courses
  • Register for FCUS Course
  • Login
Intensive Care Network
  • About Us
    • What is the ICN?
    • The ICN Story
  • Events
  • Podcast Series
    • ICN Activities
      • ICN Hot cases
      • Semantic sMatter
      • ECG Proving Ground
      • Echo Cases
      • SMACC 2013
      • ICU Radiology Cases
      • Game Changing Evidence
  • Regional Networks
    • SIN
    • BIN
  • Exams
    • Primary ANZCA
      • Pharmacology
      • Physiology
    • Primary ACEM
      • Pharmacology
      • Physiology
      • Pathology
      • Anatomy
    • Fellowship CICM
      • Notes
      • Past Papers
    • Fellowship Paeds
      • Approaches to Questions
      • Clinical Exam
      • Core ICU
      • Clinical Governance
      • Medicine
      • Surgery
    • Fellowship ANZCA
      • Notes
      • Past Papers with Answers
  • Resources
    • Links
    • The ICN meta feed
    • Reviews
      • Courses
      • Conferences
      • Websites & Blogs
      • Books & Journals
    • Clinical Resources
      • Clinical Calculators
    • Non-clinical resources
      • Research
  • Discussion Forum
    • Main Page

The NEJM Critical Care Challenge: Case 11 (Answer)

Home The NEJM Critical Care Challenge: Case 11 (Answer)

The final case of this critical care series looks at models of decision making surrounding end-of-life care and the fundamental principles of dying with dignity in the ICU.

critcare11_lg

[az_box_icon animation_loading=”yes” animation_loading_effects=”move_left” icon=”font-icon-vcard” title=”Summary of Case and Question” position=”left”] [/az_box_icon]

A 77-year-old man whose medical history includes treated hypertension and hypercholesterolemia, previous heavy alcohol intake, and mild cognitive impairment required 15 days of treatment in the ICU for septic shock due to faecal peritonitis from a perforated sigmoid colon.

After being transferred to the surgical floor, he had an unwitnessed fall from his bed suffering an acute subdural haematoma with underlying hemorrhagic contusion, for which her underwent a craniotomy for evacuation of the  haematoma. Twelve days after this procedure, during which he received no sedative medications, he remains in a coma with a best motor response of abnormal flexion on the left side. He is still receiving mechanical ventilation. The consensus opinion of treating clinicians is that he will most likely not make a functional recovery.

How should further decisions regarding ongoing management be made?

[az_box_icon animation_loading=”yes” animation_loading_effects=”move_left” icon=”font-icon-trophy” title=”Answer” position=”left”] [/az_box_icon]

The majority of respondents (81%) voted to adopt a model of shared decision making with the family- electing to meet with the family to ascertaining the patient’s wishes regarding the continuation of active medical treatment and whether the likely outcome of continued treatment – at best, placement in a nursing home with a high level of care – would be consistent with his wishes.

Most of the remaining respondents (13%) would have taken a more firm leadership roll in decision making – meeting with the family to tell them there is no hope of recovery and as such supportive care will be withdrawn.

[az_progress_bar style_progress_bar=”circle_progress” animation_loading=”yes” animation_loading_effects=”move_right” checkicon=”custom_icon” icon=”font-icon-light-bulb” field=”Discuss ” percentage=”81″]

The editors note (here) that decision making models with regard to end-of-life care vary worldwide. This is reflected in the range of comments that have been posted by physicians worldwide: while some take a more active roll in leading a family towards a decision to withdraw care, others remain neutral and merely advise, accepting a family’s decision on behalf of the patient.

The accompanying review article reports that “in one study involving surrogates of 169 critically ill patients, 56% preferred to receive a physician’s recommendation on the use of life support, 42% preferred not to receive such a recommendation”. The authors suggest that “asking families about their desire for recommendations from physicians can be a starting point for shared deliberations about care plan” and a good means of engendering trust.

Where conflict arises between treating teams and families regarding the appropriateness of ongoing life-sustaining treatment, ethics consultations have been demonstrated to be helpful for staff and families and resulted in reduced hospital/ICU stay and reduced ventilated days, without changing overall mortality.

The associated review article which covers the fundamental principles of holistic end-of-life care can be found here.

Share this
ICN Victoria: Radford & Van Dyke on Simulation & DebriefEvaluating Education by Roland
IPSN – Intensivist Parent Support Network WIN – Women in Intensive Care Network ICN UK ICN NZ ICN WA ICN VIC ICN NSW ICN QLD The ICN Story The Team Jellybean Podcasts ICN Blog SMACC Video SMACC Audio Video ECG Simulator by aclsmedicaltraining BASIC SCIENCE CLINIC Simulation Game Changing Evidence ICU Radiology Echo Guide ECHO Cases Clinical Cases EXAMHELP Jellybean Podcasts ICN Blog SMACC Video SMACC Audio Video CICM Fellowship ANZCA FELLOWSHIP PAEDS FELLOWSHIP EMERGENCY PRIMARY ANAESTHETICS PRIMARY End-o-bed-o-gram

  • About
    •  What is ICN
    •  The Team
    •  ICN NSW
    •  ICN QLD
    •  ICN VIC
    •  ICN WA
    •  ICN NZ
    •  ICN UK
  • Resources
    •  Lung US
    •  Exam Help
    •  Clinical Cases
    •  Echo Cases
    •  Echo Guide
    •  ICU Radiology
    •  Game Changing Evidence
    •  ICN Metafeed
    •  Simulation Resouces
  • Media
    •  SMACC Posters
    •  Audio
    •  Video
    •  Pecha Kuchas
  • Upskill
    •  Clinical Cases
    •  Echo Cases
    •  ICU Radiology
  • Exam Help
    •  End-o-Bed-o-Gram
    •  ICU Primary Exam
    •  CICM Fellowship
    •  ANZCA Fellowship
    •  Paeds Fellowship
    •  Emergency Primary
    •  Anaesthetics Primary

® 2025 The Intensive Care Network || All rights reserved || Disclaimer || Site Map || Contact ICN Support

Log in with your credentials

or     Create an account

Lost your password?

Forgot your details?

I remember my details

Create Account